yamdablamfollowshare
10-16-2007 10:49 AM3289 views
yamdablam says:
I think this is hilarious !
9 Comments   | Add a Comment
10-17-2007 2:44 PM
adamc
If only they could just read brains like Steve Jobs can.
10-17-2007 5:37 PM
hairball
Looks like the guy in the pic is using Vista...the meter is barely registering activity.
10-17-2007 6:32 PM
abcgirl171
okay
10-17-2007 7:58 PM
Zeke Zzzpt
Eventually Microsoft will realize that there is no cognitive stuff without it being triggered into action by some association, often by non-cognitive cues. This is how advertisers make a living. We think of (we remember) things only when we are reminded, when the thought is cued up by an association. Cognition is a cascade of thought and any given "cognitive unit" is a link in a chain. Most of the time we don't know what triggers things, mostly because the triggers and the thoughts/actions they generate are subconscious. Good luck, Microsoft.
10-17-2007 8:27 PM
thinboy00
I'm taking a psych course, and an EEG only gives you the overall state of the brain, not thoughts and feelings (nothing can do that yet, but the EEG can't even tell what parts of the brain are most active).
10-17-2007 11:25 PM
dirish
Its not as if I understood anything Zeke said, but I'm so down with it that I gotta say Go Zeke!!!!
10-18-2007 7:35 AM
Fast T friend
wouldn't it be easier if they just asked users? oh, and listen to what they told them...
10-18-2007 7:57 AM
yamdablam
You'd think...but apparently we are not reliable sources of this information. So how do you develop a system for a user who is not a reliable source of user requirements?

I reckon Bill himself came up with this idea on a night out.
"I know...lets code up a system that reads their minds!". Bill being Bill, nobody disagreed with him.

Even the diagram looks like it was drawn on a napkin in a bar.

10-18-2007 3:32 PM
Oortcloud
@thinboy
Knowing the state of the brain could still allow someone the possibility of finding out what particularly interests a person thought, right? If a person's EEG indicates the person is content, or excited, or upset then those impulses could be used to refine the stuff being shown to them. You don't really have to know what they are thinking, only if they like it or not.

The question is then, can we know if someone is happy, sad, angry, content, etc by their EEG?
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up





   
 
 
 
   
 
top scroll end
19
POPS
Colbert Is Running for President!?
pitim
by pitim  10-17-2007    7
 oh wow
49
POPS
Swearing at Work Good for You
abailart
by abailart  10-17-2007    26
 Perhaps not earth shattering news, but a reminder that much of our talk is not to convey information but to maintain group solidarity, identity etc. and answer our most basic psychological needs.
21
POPS
Baby Boomer #1 Applies For Social Security
wiccantexan
by wiccantexan  10-16-2007    6
 No Remarks
50
POPS
The New Nostradamus
syncopath
by syncopath  10-16-2007    9
 worth read the whole article. as they say: there is nothing new under the sun, but there is a lot of unknown there still 2be discovered .... -))
23
POPS
World's chronically hungry increasing by millions
arifsali
by arifsali  10-16-2007    7
 No Remarks
11
POPS
Rwanda aims to turn itself into the 'Singapore of Africa'
arifsali
by arifsali  10-16-2007    3
 No Remarks
22
POPS
Microsoft mind reading
yamdablam
by yamdablam  10-16-2007    9
 I think this is hilarious !
— end of the list —

clipweek's Oct 17 ClipCast

loading clips...
Filter
rss tools
Clipmarks
About   Clippers   Blog   Privacy   EULA   Copyright   Site Map   Forbes Digital

OK