2
POPSArmy Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba says Bush & Rumsfeld knew about Abu Ghraib torture There was a lot of speculation as to whether or not the President and Rumsfeld were aware of the extent of the conditions at Abu Ghraib, but the discussion never seemed to go anywhere. This reopens the topic for discussion and I'd say it damn near concludes the issue in its indictment of Rumsfeld. At best, Taguba said, "Rumsfeld was in denial ... The photographs were available to him -- if he wanted to see them."
2
POPSBush admits to ignoring military intelligence. Bush is effectively saying Shinseki was right & Rumsfeld was wrong . This only goes to support Lt. Gen Paul Van Riper's take on the original civilian leadership , "You don't have to serve in the military to understand it, but if you haven't served, then you at least ought to school yourself. I don't believe either Mr. McNamara or Mr. Rumsfeld are professionally schooled. They're ignorant of military operations, of strategy and policy. The effect is normally they're disdainful of those they lead & then, as they begin to increase their power, they become arrogant, & they're unwilling to accept advice, even though they claim they are willing to accept the advice. But by their very actions, either relieving people or publicly humiliating people, you don't get the sort of push back you need to have the dialogue, the understanding, the debate out of which you will synthesize better ideas."
0
POPSLt. Gen. Gregory Newbold: Replace Rumsfeld. So what is to be done? We need fresh ideas and fresh faces. That means, as a first step, replacing Rumsfeld and many others unwilling to fundamentally change their approach. The troops in the Middle East have performed their duty. Now we need people in Washington who can construct a unified strategy worthy of them. It is time to send a signal to our nation, our forces and the world that we are uncompromising on our security but are prepared to rethink how we achieve it. It is time for senior military leaders to discard caution in expressing their views and ensure that the President hears them clearly. And that we won't be fooled again. Slate said it best, "Newbold resigned his position in late 2002—quite a gesture, since he was widely regarded as a candidate for the next Marine Corps commandant. His fellow officers knew he resigned over the coming war in Iraq. The public and the president did not."( 1 )
2
POPSLawrence Wilkerson (Powell's Chief of Staff) criticizes Iraq intelligence & planning for the war.
Here's what the plan was: The plan devised principally in Undersecretary of Defense Douglas Feith's office, and I have to believe, if Rumsfeld is the controller, the leader he says he is, that he was fully cognizant of this, and I don't think he would have been cognizant of it without the blessings of the vice president either. The plan was to put Jay Garner, General Jay Garner, in his organization, called ORHA, on the ground in Iraq for maybe 90 to 120 days, install Ahmed Chalabi and his INC colleagues, or some other look-alike, in control, and then leave, withdrawing most of the major military force in the process, if not all of it, in a very short period of time. This is ineptitude and incompetence of the first order. Ever since that plan failed, we've been in a pickup game and now we've transmogrified the mission from imminent threat and WMD into spreading democracy. The full transcript can be found here .
2
POPSAndrew Card & Laura Bush try to convince the President to replace Rumsfeld For those of you not keeping count, all the people listed below have either suggested, called for, or supported removing Rumsfeld: Andrew Card, Laura Bush, Gen. Shinseki , Gen. Tony Zinni , Lt. Gen. Gregory Newbold , Maj. Gen. Paul D. Eaton , Maj. Gen. John R.S. Batiste , Col. Thomas Hammes , Army Sec. Thomas White , Col. Lawrence Wilkerson , Stephen Herbits , Gen. William Odom , Gen. Wesley Clark , Lt. Gen. Paul Van Riper And, Powell may be joining the list. For more on this read here .
1
POPSMaj. Gen. Paul Eaton: Iraq Plan Flawed. Mr. Rumsfeld came in to transform the US military. To turn the Army into a lighter, more lethal armed force. In fact, Rumsfeld's vision is a force designed to meet a Warsaw Pact type force more effectively - but we are not fighting the Warsaw Pact. We are fighting an insurgency: a distributed low-tech, high-concept war that demands greater numbers of ground forces, not fewer. Mr. Rumsfeld won't acknowledge this fact. And he has failed to adapt to the current situation. He has tried and continues to fight this war on the cheap. I wrote the op-ed piece in March of this year after I read the QDR. The QDR reads like a new more potent counter Warsaw pact force. It does not read like the force we need today to prosecute the foreign policy embarked upon by this administration. The President is not well served by this Secretary of Defense, a man history will not treat kindly. So what to do? Replace the Secretary of Defense with a proven leader who has a visi...
3
POPSMaj. Gen. John R.S. Batiste rips Rumsfeld apart. Here's a transcript from the beginning of the speech, I left the military on principle on Nov 1, 2005, after more than 31 years of service. I walked away from promotion and a promising future serving our country. I hung up my uniform because I came to the gut wrenching realization that I could do more good for my soldiers and their families out of uniform. I'm a Westpoint graduate, the son and son-in-law of veteran career infantry soldiers, a two time combat veteran with extensive service in Bosnia, Kosovo and Iraq and a life-long Republican. Bottom line, our nation is in peril. Our Defense Departments leadership is extraordinarily bad and our congress is only today, five years in to the war, beginning to exercise its oversight responsibilities. This is all about accountability and setting our nation up for victory. There is no substitute for victory, and I believe we must complete what we started in Iraq and Afghanistan. Donald Rumsfeld is not a competent war time leader." [
2
POPSCol. Thomas Hammes calls for Rumsfeld to step down, in his testimony before the DPC Thomas Hammes was also responsible for managing bases, facilities & logistics supporting training & operations of the Iraqi army in 2004. His speech is highly critical of the civilian leadership and its lack of planning. At the end he says, And that brings me to my final point. There have been significant failures in leadership by both civilian and military leaders. None of the suggestions I've made will be carried out unless the leadership believes it needs to be done. To date senior military leaders have failed to speak out for their troops. The troops and their families are suffering for it. At a more senior level the Secretary of Defense has not acknowledged the numerous serious mistakes made to date. His refusal to see the problems means he cannot solve them. It is time for him to provide the nation the last in a long series of services and step down.
5
POPSRumsfeld's Personal Aide attacks his Post War Planning Stephen Herbits, a lawyer and longtime Rumsfeld friend going back to 1967. Herbits had been one of Rumsfeld's civilian special assistants during his first Pentagon tour. Rumsfeld made him a consultant with a license to analyze current problems, and he functioned as a management fix-it man, somewhat as Karl Rove did for Bush.
4
POPSRumsfeld says he won't resign The defense secretary and Bush have faced growing criticism for their handling of the Iraq war as violence there has escalated, U.S. casualties have mounted and public support for the conflict has declined. Fueling the debate in recent days was the release of a classified intelligence report that concluded that the Iraq war has helped fuel a new generation of extremists and increased the overall terrorist threat.
7
POPSA Portrait of Bush as a Victim of His Own Certitude (Book Review) The New York Times with what promises to be only the first in many reviews of Bob Woodward's highly anticiapted new book, State of Denial . The writer said that when Bush invited key Republicans to the White House to discuss Iraq, the president told them, 'I will not withdraw even if Laura and Barney are the only ones supporting me,"' referring to his wife and Scottish terrier.
10
POPSRumsfeld believes there should be more positive news about the war in Iraq. The line that really bothers me, "More media attention was given to U.S. soldiers' abuse of Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib than to the fact that Sgt. 1st Class Paul Ray Smith received the Medal of Honor." I have to ask, does Rumsfeld honestly believe that a Medal of Honor winner is more newsworthy than the United States torturing it's captives and breaking the rules set in place by the Geneva convention? And if so, does Rumsfeld have the perspective needed to address the problems we are now facing as the war heads in to its fourth year? Comments welcomed.
Newest Clips
see Newest Clips
1
Latest Pops
Latest Comments
Most Pops
Tags
Print
Save
Turn on live update