Clipmarks
masburyfollowshare
7-15-2008 5:48 PM
708 views
masbury says:
Newly released government documents suggest Salim Hamdan was forced to remain awake for nearly two months
27 Comments   | Add a Comment
7-15-2008 7:34 PM
debbyski
Torture doesn't work. Just ask McCain.
7-16-2008 6:48 PM
sillysam
BS McCain admits he caved after awhile. During training we are told how to resist but that everyone eventually has a breaking point.
7-16-2008 6:50 PM
sillysam
And the world record for not sleeping is eleven days. SO this is BS.
7-16-2008 7:26 PM
ratilfar
What did McCain give to the North Vietnamese exactly? A sign confession of war crimes. As for getting accurate info, it doesn't work.

And your examples only work for people who are being trained for this stuff, no some schmuck who gets picked up from the streets of Kariachi or Chicago.
7-17-2008 7:13 PM
RecordSage
50 is very nice round number... BS it is, just as sillysam accurately pointed out.
7-17-2008 7:15 PM
RecordSage
masbury, I hope you don't think this being too forward of me, but do you have children? and if so - were you actively involved in their day-to-day activities right after their birth?
7-17-2008 7:16 PM
debbyski
Yes Record and Silly the shit if really flying and what the hell does Mas having any children have to do with this clip?
7-17-2008 8:07 PM
ratilfar
Because if shows that in some perverted way that he is not willing to protect them, to do everything in his power to punish the evil doers. Problem is that a) no convictions means no way of knowing if any of these people are evil doers and b) teaching or endorsing torture is the cowards way. I would not teach that to my kids, I doubt Mas would do the same.

That is real morality, not situational morality and no ifs, ends or buts....
7-17-2008 8:07 PM
esundby
Lol, I had sleep deprivation for 56 days during basic training... As they describe it, deprivation consists of waking the prisoners up in the middle of the night and making them change cells... Hardly worth of the shock and awe that this headline is attempting to provoke. Also, doesn't seem too extreme considering this guy was captured with 2 surface to air missiles in his car and was Osama's driver and probably has critical information as to the location of Osama or Taliban forces. Information that could not only end the war but save lives while doing it... Masbury wants us to focus on how tired the war criminal is rather than what his role in the killing of innocent Americans was. Al...
7-17-2008 8:18 PM
ratilfar
Yeah, please believe the official line. Oh and how much info could he have after 3 or 4 years. Intel is time sensitive. Also I doubt that the technique does not match the training you describe, other wise they could not break him, I mean a guy used to living in the Pakistani boonies. So either it doesn't even work as described or it is a total waste of time.
7-17-2008 8:24 PM
ratilfar
And this is just the tip of the iceberg:

Sean Baker has seizures an average of four times a week. 60 Minutes Wednesday went to see him a few weeks ago in a New York hospital.

Baker, a National Guardsman, was working last year as a military policeman in the Guantanamo Bay prison when other MPs injured him during a training drill. It was a drill during which Baker was only obeying orders.

"I was assaulted by these individuals," says Baker. "Pure and simple."
7-17-2008 8:25 PM
ratilfar
"They wanted to make training a little more realistic," says Baker. "Put this orange suit on."

Locke gave Baker a code word – red - to shout out in case of trouble. From under the bunk, Baker heard the extraction team coming down the causeway. In sworn statements, however, four members of the team said they thought they were going after a real detainee.

"My face was down. And of course, they’re pushing it down against the steel floor, you know, my right temple, pushing it down against the floor," recalls Baker. "And someone’s holding me by the throat, using a pressure point on me and holding my throat. And I used the word, ‘red.’ At that point I, you know...
7-17-2008 8:25 PM
ratilfar
Baker started having a seizure that morning and was whisked to the Naval Hospital at Guantanamo. "[He looked like] he'd had the crap beat out of him. He had a concussion. I mean, it was textbook," says Riley. "[His face} was blank. You know, a dead stare, like he was seeing you, but really looking through you."

Baker was airlifted to the Portsmouth Naval Medical Center in Virginia, where doctors determined he had suffered an injury to the right side of his brain. He was released after four days, and Baker says he requested to go back to Cuba.

"I wanted to go back and perform my duties," says Baker. "I wanted to be back with my unit."

Baker ...
7-17-2008 8:26 PM
ratilfar
Documents released by the FBI offer new details about the interrogation practices used to question prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, the Associated Press reports this morning.

AP says "FBI agents documented more than two dozen incidents of possible mistreatment at the Guantanamo Bay military base, including one detainee whose head was wrapped in duct tape for chanting the Quran and another who pulled out his hair after hours in a sweltering room."

The documents show special agents were very concerned about the consequences of having interrogators impersonate FBI investigators. "The...
7-17-2008 8:33 PM
esundby
I'm not sure what your point is since you've gone way off course here but in response, I say if they don't give up information they should be shot... Anything less than that is fine with me. This is war.
7-17-2008 8:35 PM
ratilfar
The point is that like I said sleep deprivation is just the tip of the iceberg. Oh and that torturers are cowards.
7-17-2008 8:35 PM
ratilfar
Not my fault that reading comprehension is a lost art.
7-17-2008 8:38 PM
ratilfar
7-17-2008 8:46 PM
esundby
Not treating terrorists like terrorists is idiocy. Which is worse?
7-17-2008 8:46 PM
masbury
I was intimately involved with my children from the moment of the onset of labor; in fact, we had some serious illness after the birth of the second in which my four-year-old and I were the only ones standing. That is NOTHING like systematic sleep deprivation, which is not about "how tired" someone is, but is about induced pyschosis. Do you honestly think the KGB did it to make people tired? Consider this comment from the BBC of John Schlapobersky, consultant psychotherapist to the
Medical Foundation for Victims of Torture, who was himself tortured through
sleep deprivation, in his case in apartheid South Africa in the 1960s:...
7-17-2008 8:49 PM
masbury
hallucination and psychotic episodes.
It's been used by torturing regimes around the world, who found it a way to induce unbearable suffering.
And, of course, like all forms of torture, it produces the evidence that the victim presumes the torturers want to hear - which is utterly unreliable.
7-17-2008 8:56 PM
masbury
esundby: The CIA alerted the Bush Admin years ago to the fact that a third of the detainees were arrested by mistake. Yet, from all we can tell, they were all interrogated similarly.

Many of them are no more terrorists than you are. Your comment about "treating terrorists like terrorists" is certainly appropriate - once it has been proven that they are terrorists. Shooting them, prior to a conviction, is simply murder and a war crime.

We were able to prosecute the worst of the Nazis at Nuremburg, and the world agreed with the outcome, because the trials were just and fair. If we react from the gut now, we become the bad guys. Democracy demands a higher response.
7-17-2008 8:57 PM
ratilfar
Not treating terrorists like terrorists is idiocy. Which is worse?
What does that mean, exactly?

Has terrorism been elevated to some kind of special crime that allows you to throw courage,morality and basic common sense out of the window?

So if I call you a terrorist I can beat the living crap out of you?

Yeah that makes a lot of sense.
7-17-2008 8:58 PM
ratilfar
Or is sharing the same concern for human life as the Inquisition, the Nazis, Pinochet, Stalinist, Maoist and Communist North Vietnam a sign of progress?
7-17-2008 9:00 PM
ratilfar
But then again, morality only works in the right kind of situation. When it becomes inconinient it gets tossed out the window.
7-17-2008 9:00 PM
ratilfar
inconvinient.
7-17-2008 9:30 PM
RecordSage
@masbury - sorry to hear about your kids' issues, have those myself and can certainly empathize... but you clearly understood what I was driving at. Yes, the KGB used the tactic, although in a different setting (i.e. there were no prayers 6 times a day there like there are at Gitmo)... they would place a person naked in a cold and very small room (so small you couldn't sit or lie down) and then they would continuously drop cold water droplets from the top on that person and wake them up several times per night.
With your description of involvement with the kids - you know (better than debbyski obviously) just how difficult it is to first get used to lack of sleep and then dealing with it ...
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up
Embed This Clip In Your Site...

New from the makers of Clipmarks:  Amplify.com - Don't just share the news...Amplify it!

OK