Clipmarks
righthandfollowshare
1-16-2008 1:34 PM
2433 views
tags:,
righthand says:
...Emerging from the chamber, he believes the test to push his life to its limit has failed.

Nor has he any recollection of his inability to reopen his oxygen supply or to put his mask back on.

"I fooled you, didn't I?" he says triumphantly.

"No, Michael, death was your final destination today," says Meeuwsen, who trains fighter pilots for the Royal Netherlands Air Force. "Hans saved your life."

Portillo travelled to a military training base in the Netherlands to research the effects of oxygen starvation, technically known as hypoxia, on the body.

His quest is unusually dark. What he really wants to know is if hypoxia can offer a humane method of killing people in the 55 countries that still have the death penalty on their statute books.
7 Comments   | Add a Comment
1-16-2008 1:52 PM
righthand
Portillo finds himself at the grandly titled Centre for Man and Aviation in Soesterberg, Netherlands.

There, he is given access to the altitude chamber and also the air force's centrifuge which permits a person, usually a fighter pilot, to pull a potentially fatal 9-G, nine times the force of gravity.

....becoming hypoxic does his intellect no good. As pressure inside the altitude chamber is reduced, Portillo is subjected to a series of infantile tests – and fails spectacularly.

"What is eight minus three?" asks Wittenberg. "Four," Portillo replies.

...He says today: "At the end, they turned to me and said, 'How do you feel?' and I replied, 'Great! I got all the questions right!'"

Porti...
— Comment removed by clipper —
1-16-2008 2:15 PM
righthand
...Portillo realises the multi-million-pound machines placed at his disposal by the Royal Netherlands Air Force could not replace every noose, gas chamber, electric chair or lethal injection in the world. But, in a research facility at Bristol University, he witnesses footage of a pig truffling for apples in a box filled with noxious gas.

The gas sends the animal into a hypoxic state by painlessly reducing the oxygen in its bloodstream. The pig breathes in the gas, staggers and falls unconscious to the ground. But when it comes to, it immediately returns to the apples, proving they have no association with fear or suffering.

"It was," says Portillo, "simplicity itself."

Were the ga...
1-16-2008 3:36 PM
kkcapricorn
I think it is a noble quest.
This talk of pain, punishment, and justice are human concepts and as with all human concepts there are numerous opinions upon how to define these words.
1-16-2008 4:08 PM
aj_franklin
I am a pilot. I have been in NASA's hyperbaric chamber here in Houston for such a test of altitude response by the human body. At 26,000 (hypothetical) feet I was adding a column of numbers used at the center to determine when you "lose it" and passed out cold. But I was nowhere near dead. Only unconscious.

I came to within seconds of having my O2 mask restored. Only slightly queasy. I don't think it is a method of execution that can be depended on for results. Too many people would only pass out through the limits of the chamber, and then wake up when returned to sea level...presumably to be buried!
1-16-2008 10:36 PM
Antara
Interesting.

I wanna try it!
1-16-2008 11:54 PM
BartendingBear
My understanding is that helium or nitrogen make for very efficient oxygen replacement, leading to a sure and remarkably peaceful death. What is so hard about figuring this out? Just Google it and it is all there.
1-17-2008 4:47 AM
righthand
Correct and simple. First unconscious and then death.

This was a BBC Horizon documentary. The site that I quote is really a transcript.
The gas sends the animal into a hypoxic state by painlessly reducing the oxygen in its bloodstream. The pig breathes in the gas, staggers and falls unconscious to the ground. But when it comes to, it immediately returns to the apples, proving they have no association with fear or suffering.

Were the gas mix and method of delivery to be converted for a human being, they would be unconscious within seconds and dead within perhaps a minute, their final moment filled with self-belief and happiness. It would be cheap, infallible, painless and, ultimatel...
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up
Embed This Clip In Your Site...

New from the makers of Clipmarks:  Amplify.com - Don't just share the news...Amplify it!

OK