I have a hard time believing this is good, but on the other hand, I do love a good peanut-butter-and-pickle sandwich, so maybe I'd like this too.

Peanut butter and pickle? Are you pulling my (everyone's) leg?

That was my reaction when I first heard of it (from my late grandfather) but he was so enthusiastic that I gave it a try and was hooked.

Sweet or dill?

Oh gross Enbar! Peanut butter and pickle sandwiches? That's enough to blast your taste buds into outer space!

Dill, definitely. Don't knock it till you tried it. It's best on real dark pumpernickel.

I'll try it, Enbar, when I can psyche myself up for it. Sounds quite disgusting.

Dill, definitely. Don't knock it till you tried it. It's best on real dark pumpernickel.

Totally seconding the dark pumpernickel recommendation for peanut butter + dill pickle (well, I personally prefer pickle relish with my peanut butter) sandwiches.

I have half a mind to start following your clips based on this one shared food preference of ours, enbar.

(well, I personally prefer pickle relish with my peanut butter)

I think I just threw-up a little in my the back of my mouth.

@patchworkthreads Listen to these Philistines! I'd be willing to bet not one of them will ever try it (true conservatives avoid new things, right?). But they'll feel perfectly comfortable describing it as disgusting nonetheless.

If you are referring to me (being Conservative), how could I describe it as disgusting when I haven't tried it? I said ...sounds, but excuse me...I didn't see debbyski's comment. Then again she is not a Conservative so she must have ran straight to the fridge and slopped her up one ( a little southern casual lingo that you repressive types love so much. Hope you don't mind).
I just don't happen to have pumpernickel at this time and the pickles in my refridgerator are of the Sweet-hot variety.

On the contrary, I am eager to try try it.

to NOT have pumpernickel