Clipmarks
   
  
   
seano77followshare
7-6-2007 8:22 PM
476 views
seano77 says:
Read More From Source..
23 Comments   | Add a Comment
7-7-2007 7:36 PM
AcesLucky
The presence of evil in the world is considered by some to be solid evidence against the existence of God. I think it proves just the opposite.
I think it proves neither.

If there is no god, there would still be good, and there would still be evil. See? Injecting a god where none is required is the confirmation bias I've been telling you about all along. You simply START with a conclusion (god exists) and seek to make the information or reasoning "fit" the conclusion you already had.

It's intellectual dishonesty. I've been trying to bring it to your attention.
7-7-2007 11:28 PM
seano77
I cannot deny that I start with a conclusion.

That is, God's
Holy Spirit lives in me and his word works in my life and the life of
my family and friends and fellow Christians around the world. I don't
really have a choice about that. Its undeniable. Although I believe I
try to remain as neutral as possible when examining your evidence. I
think thats pretty intellectually honest?

But don't you have
the exact same pre-assumptions (God doesn't exist) and you work from
there. Making things fit? Isn't that a bias?

Every argument you put at Christianity has to be put just as harshly to atheism, or whatever you choose to believe.

IF
you presented me with suitable evidence that there was no Go...
7-8-2007 1:23 AM
AcesLucky
But don't you have the exact same pre-assumptions (God doesn't exist) and you work from there. Making things fit?
Nope. That would be intellectually dishonest. I do not START from the position that there is no god. I just don't insert one whenever a gap exists between the evidence and my understanding of the evidence.

"..God's Holy Spirit lives in me ... and my family and friends.."
See? But I guess god's holy spirit DOESN'T live in the suicide bomber?

It's all "pretend". It's all make believe. Even between you and your friends, you couldn't prove any holy spirit if your lives depended on it.

You KNOW this is the real truth; that the truth you pretend i...
7-8-2007 1:54 AM
seano77
I just don't insert one whenever a gap exists between the evidence and my understanding of the evidence.
I don't do that. I take the evidence and examine it for what it is, just like anyone else. I'm not sure where you've got that idea from?
The thing is, no evidence you have presented has pointed to anything other than God.

But I guess god's holy spirit DOESN'T live in the suicide bomber?
I'm not sure how many Christian suicide bombers there have been in history. But even if there were I'd say that since the teachings of Christ and the Bible contradict that action, then they may not be Christians.
Whereas the Islamic faith endorses those actions in the Quran...
7-8-2007 1:55 AM
seano77
..I think I'm honestly thinking these issues through-
7-8-2007 4:16 AM
JohnWaterman
Atheism is not a Belief that there is no God, it is an absence of belief in any god(s).

If atheism is a belief then not collecting stamps is a hobby.
7-8-2007 12:56 PM
AcesLucky
Me:
I just don't insert one whenever a gap exists between the evidence and my understanding of the evidence.
You:
I don't do that. I take the evidence and examine it for what it is, just like anyone else. I'm not sure where you've got that idea from?
Here, again, I'll show you where I got the idea from:
--

Notice you responded to:
(Me):
Do you mean that you couldn't tell that child molestation, rape, and murder are evil WITHOUT a god saying so?
You:
No, I'm saying that without God creating us in a way that feels empathy and a sense of injustice when these terrible crimes are committed then the world would be in chaos.
--
See. Y...
7-9-2007 5:07 AM
seano77
See. You just gave a perfect example of what you said you didn't do! You simply inserted a god at the point where your reasoning faltered.
So I'm supposed to examine the evidence which points to God without mentioning God? I could accuse you of the same thing. Your inserting that there is no God where your reasoning failed. But my reasoning is not failing. I'm honestly examining the evidence and coming to the conclusion of God.

We can have a sense of justice because we can feel
Thats rubbish. Feel because we have a nervous system? Give me a break. Please provide some evidence apart form God that has the capacity to explain:

1. N...
7-9-2007 12:35 PM
AcesLucky
So I'm supposed to examine the evidence which points to God without mentioning God?
Same trick, just in the form of a question. You're supposed to examine the evidence and find out what was its cause. If any evidence led you to a god, then you should be able to PRODUCE a god. And anyone else should be able to find a god from the evidence you examined. So where is this god? (No mataphors here please. The real thing only, thank you.)

"Feel because we have a nervous system? Give me a break."
Not much science in your education, eh. Tell you what; since you won't accept it from me, go to your medical doctor, and take along a good size brick.

In the presence ...
7-10-2007 4:08 AM
seano77
You're supposed to examine the evidence and find out what was its cause. If any evidence led you to a god, then you should be able to PRODUCE a god
Thats like saying prove to me you love someone. You can't prove that you love someone. He's not a science experiment. You cannot produce your love in physical form. I can see the effects of it on your famliy, people you love etc. But you can't prove you love someone like the way your asking me to prove God. But we both know you love. And we both know God exists. We can see the evidence. We can see the effects on my life and the effects on Christians all around the world. We can see the detailed creation. What ...
7-10-2007 11:19 AM
AcesLucky
Isn't it a coincidence that it fits perfectly into the God we claim created the universe?
The things you claim prove god, (love, probability, justice, etc..) are arbitrary. You may as well say, "see, clouds exist...therefore god."

It is clear that you have been led to believe that interesting things equals god. I do not fault you for this.

I used to believe these things too. Until one day (quite by accident) I decided that god could not be stupid [assumed by the definition of omniscience].

Holding to that belief, it became clear that certain things could not have been inspired by god as I was told (because those things would make god stupid).

Like the stars being created...
7-10-2007 11:12 PM
seano77
Thank You for being honest.

I see your point.

But are you really willing to risk your potential eternity on the dating of stars, which could possibly be found to be false in a couple of hundred years?

Are you willing to risk your potential eternity on the fact that microscopic germs make us sick?

This link shows some examples of how the bible held information which science had only recently discovered as true:

http://www.livingwaters.com/witnessingtool/scienceconfirmsthebible.shtml

From this link it as quite apparent that God knows more than the 1st Century man and we still haven't found cures to everything and we still don't knnow how everything exists.

I cannot see God's stupidity....
7-11-2007 11:29 AM
AcesLucky
I see your point.
Nope. I think you missed it completely.

But then, it's clear -- you're not interested in the truth. You're interested in salvation.

You've been told that you're inherently evil, and that you must BELIEVE and subscribe to certain dogma to be cleansed from it, so you can live forever and avoid eternal torment.

You are simply afraid. They made you believe in a monster that's all loving and all hateful at the same time. But you can get on his good side by (your donations) believing it!

You had to sacrifice your integrity in order to believe it. And look at the results. You'll believe anything.

And it's sad.

I can only hope you don't go around kil...
7-11-2007 10:01 PM
seano77
you're not interested in the truth. You're interested in salvation.
But when that truth is salvation then..

You are simply afraid
"The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom" (Prov. 1:7)

But you can get on his good side by (your donations) believing it!
Nah.. salvation isn't through donations. It's repentance and faith in Jesus and trusting Him with your life. I think your also missing something- That is the relationship with Him on earth which is just so amazing when your saved.
You had to sacrifice your integrity in order to believe it.
I gained my integrity when I believed! My actions no longer go against ...
7-12-2007 2:42 AM
AcesLucky
Remember, 9/11 was a faith-based initiative.

Killing?...The Bible doesn't condone killing.
Ever heard of President Bush? Ever heard of the Crusades, or the Inquisition? Did you know that there were several inquisitions, spanning over 600 years of Christian atrocities of murder and torture?

You know nothing about the history of your own religion, do you? You take what they tell you, and do no investigation on your own. Even if you read the bible (instead of having it spoon fed you from a pulpit) you'll find god-ordered atrocity after atrocity.

You said you believed the bible? How do you deal with god telling Moses to kill every person in a town that won't ...
7-12-2007 3:15 AM
seano77
Why did America vote for him if he's a killer? Huh? I'm sure without the non-christian vote he wouldn't have got elected-

Ever heard of the Crusades, or the Inquisition?
People killing people who claim to be Christians are not Christians. Hence the 1 John passage.

Anyway, what happens to all the atheists who kill people? Ah..thats ok don't worry, life is meaningless anyway, right?

You take what they tell you, and do no investigation on your own.
Not true. That would be intellectually dishonest, right?

Now therefore kill every male among the little ones..
I'm glad you brought this one up. This is another example of when people rebel G...
7-12-2007 8:22 AM
JohnWaterman
"Hell is God's way of saying "Ok". These people rejected God."

just too bizarre.
7-12-2007 8:58 AM
seano77
Bizarre?
7-12-2007 11:17 AM
JohnWaterman
?
7-12-2007 11:33 AM
AcesLucky
Why did America vote for him if he's a killer? Huh?
You forget, he's also a liar. Did you know that well over 100,000 innocent civilians were killed in the name of the Iraq war, a war based on a lie? (Independent agencies not connected with the Bush regime put the figure at around 600,000.) Is Bush a Christian? THAT WAS MY POINT.

"People killing people who claim to be Christians are not Christians."
Obviously you were not aware that the Inquisitions were commissioned by and led by [successive] the Pope! Is the Pope Christian? THAT WAS MY POINT.

"Anyway, what happens to all the atheists who kill people?"
Hopefully, like anyone else, they'...
7-12-2007 11:46 AM
JohnWaterman
go for it girl!
7-13-2007 3:05 AM
seano77
I don't know if your very grateful for your President trying to protect your country..
For
me to judge his faith, not up to me. But whether a Christian, Pope or
President kills someone, that is not an argument to say that Christ's
teachings are false or that God does not exist.


And finally, your god orders mass killings all over the bible and
partakes of it himself over and over again. CAN YOU UNDERSTAND MY POINT?
Yes, I understand your point- I explained that previous one in Numbers about the people rebelling against Him. I don't see how that has any relevance, especially if you don't believe in Him anyway? Saying,"that man is naughty" is no argument against his existance.
...
7-13-2007 2:34 PM
AcesLucky
Christ's teachings are perfect, Christians following Jesus are not. Understand?
One day you're really going to need an honest answer.
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up
Embed This Clip In Your Site...

New from the makers of Clipmarks:  Amplify.com - Don't just share the news...Amplify it!

OK