Hahaha i gotto do that sometime...write a note with my email n put it in a sturdy bottle n toss it in the sea ^_^ People, always remember to reply to messages u find in bottles ok! Keep the romance alive!

There really is no way they could know this:

but there is no way it could happen

Just because it shouldn't doesn't mean it couldn't. And not knowing the "how that happened" really adds to the romance of the mystery. That grinch is just trying to be a wonder killer.

I agree - there's no way to rule it out!