Clipmarks
ghgroenewoldfollowshare
7-15-2007 9:28 PM398 views
6 Comments   | Add a Comment
7-15-2007 11:15 PM
cniq_cniq
Strange...After reading both the blog entry and the source article, I have no clue as to what prompted the blogger's self-described rant. The article as I read it tells of a community coming together in support of a sick child and her family, not of a religious fantasy. I'd be willing to answer many of his criticisms of prayer and the false impressions he offers of those who pray, but it would give undue credit to his faulty premise.
7-18-2007 11:18 AM
AcesLucky
"After reading ..., I have no clue as to what prompted the blogger's self-described rant."
You probably missed some of the points, so here are a few that explain why the rant.

"These prayer circles, this continuing belief that healing will happen if enough people pray -- and, implicitly, if the girl herself is godly enough -- is setting the poor child up for a death bathed in self-recrimination. Evidently, it's already happening."

"I must also say this: there's something perverse to the point of revulsion in the idea of a god that will heal the girl if enough people pray for her."

[i]"If you pray for cure and don't get it, and if you believe that prayin...
7-18-2007 12:23 PM
cniq_cniq
Give me a break. None of that is in the source article upon which the blogger dumped. I perfectly understood the ranting itself. I'm just left wondering whether or not you and the author actually read the article. Or, if instead, both or you have created your own strawman to swipe at.
7-19-2007 9:49 AM
monalisa
There are shit loads of thingy out there far worse than a baby girl dying.I will give it to you as an assignment to get me just three
7-19-2007 3:13 PM
AcesLucky
Exhibit 1

I have no clue as to what prompted the blogger's self-described rant.
Uh, the prayer, dude. And the effect it's having on the child.

Exhibit 2

I perfectly understood the ranting itself.
Go back to Exhibit 1.

====

From the source article: "Hundreds believing what Gloria believes: Instead of a medical breakthrough for her terminal illness, God will heal her."

From the source article: "When her parents ask if she wishes to attend a prayer session at the Fantozzis' house, Gloria responds with a word she never used to say: "No.""

From the source article: ""Oh my gosh, we've been filling up the heavens with prayer,...
Login to Comment.  Not a member yet? Sign up





Embed This Clip In Your Site...


OK